WUFT News

No, Pedro Bravo Didn’t Ask Siri Where to Stash His Roommate’s Body

By on August 13th, 2014
A screen shot of a Siri search from a Facebook cache viewed on Pedro Bravo's cell phone is shown to the jury during Bravo's murder trial in courtroom 1B of the Alachua County Criminal Justice Center Tuesday, August 12, 2014.  Bravo is accused of killing University of Florida student Christian Aguilar.

Doug Finger / Pool/The Gainesville Sun

A screen shot of a Siri search from a Facebook cache viewed on Pedro Bravo's cell phone is shown to the jury during Bravo's murder trial in courtroom 1B of the Alachua County Criminal Justice Center Tuesday, August 12, 2014. Bravo is accused of killing University of Florida student Christian Aguilar.

There has been a great deal of attention on the Pedro Bravo trial happening here in Gainesville. Unfortunately, some of the most recent news just isn’t true.

Update: Read the transcript from the trial where the assistant state attorney questions the GPD detective on the image of a Siri search.

Following a story posted by WPXI and other Cox Media affiliates, many national and international media outlets are running with a story that Bravo, who is accused of killing Christian Aguilar, asked Siri where to stash his “roommate’s” body.

Two things are wrong with that narrative: according to Gainesville Police, and our reporters in the courtroom, Detective Goeckel never testified that Bravo performed that Siri search, and Aguilar and Bravo were not roommates.

GPD public information officer Ben Tobias took to Twitter this morning to start to debunk some of the rumors:

Other reporters covering the trial also chimed in:

Some in the national media initially met the questioning with some surprise:

https://twitter.com/jaketapper/status/499579239474405376

Perhaps we can chalk this up to the old adage “never let the facts get in the way of a good story?”

Stay tuned to WUFT News for our from-the-courthouse coverage of the Bravo trial, including our live feed and @WUFTPedroBravo twitter feed. Or check out some of the excellent work by our friends at the Alligator.

UPDATE 3:30 p.m.: Ryan Giusti, Cox Media Group managing editor for the national content desk, has contacted WUFT News and said that the report did not originate with WPXI, but rather with Action News Jax in Jacksonville, Fla., another station in the Cox Media Group. The national and international press aggregating this information have been linking to the WPXI report, which is why we identified it above.

Update 2:30 p.m. WUFT News has pulled the footage from yesterday’s trial where Detective Goeckel discussed the image which prompted the reports that Bravo did a search on Siri. Assistant State Attorney Bill Ezzell questions the detective:

“You indicated the State’s H-I [Siri Screenshot] came from the camera roll or the saved images folder you could say of this iPhone. Is that fair?

Goeckel: “It comes out as images, it’s in the Facebook cache is what it’s in.”

“And so, because it’s coming from somewhere off the internet, or something like that, Facebook is a social networking site accessed by the internet, is that fair to say?”

Goeckel: “Yes.”

“Might that explain why this screen capture indicates an AT&T provider as opposed to Verizon which is the carrier of the defendant’s cell phone?”

Goeckel: “Correct”

“Might that explain – or let me ask you this – do you know what this screen capture is of? What we would call this?”

Goeckel: “This would be from a Siri.”

“Okay, was Siri as a program, was she available on the iPhone 4?”

Goeckel: “No.”

“Okay, how could a Siri image appear on an iPhone 4?”

Goeckel: “In this case it was cached on Facebook, it was viewed on Facebook with the phone.”

Editor’s note: Tapper reached out via twitter about our initial characterization of his skepticism about the tweets. We’ve updated it to reflect his questioning as surprise that media outlets ran with the story.


This entry was posted in Local and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Butterfly Girl

    Many people do not understand cellulars and their technology today, especially older people. The bottom line here is that Pedro’s phone had this image, wherever he got it from whether it was Facebook or from another person texting him the image as an attachment, HE HAD the image on his cellular from someone who initially searched it on an I Phone with Siri. The way they handled the questioning of this is confusing. People immediately thought that Christian was Pedro’s roommate which was not the case either. The important thing to see here is why would anyone want to know how to hide a person, be it a roommate, a friend or a stranger.

    • MayaGold

      To state the obvious. The reason an image like that would be on anyone’s phone and/or facebook is because it’s funny.

      People ask siri all sorts of ludicrous things, and the face that you get answers amuses a lot of people. Plus that search doesn’t say “roommate’s body” it says “roommate”. Perhaps the searcher’s landlord was coming over and was under the impression the searcher lived alone – an innocent (unless you’re the landlord) search giving sinister answers is funny. Or perhaps it did mean body, doesn’t mean the searcher was doing it with any sort of malicious intent, more just to see what siri would say.

  • CatCisco

    well, if he had this image on his cell phone, from someone who initially searched it, then who was this person? Or if it was facebook, was it someone else’s facebook? Who send it to him? Doesn’t that make you curious? Or do you just want to blame all of it on him? Is it that simple to you?

 

More Stories in Local

Photo courtesy of Creative Commons

Unexpected Fireworks Leave Some Veterans On Edge

Veterans who suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder may face obstacles during the holiday weekend. Military With PTSD, a nonprofit organization, has started a campaign to help educate people about the effects of fireworks on people with PTSD.


The confederate soldier statue stands outside of the Alachua County Administration Building. Due to recent controversy in the nation, the monument's downtown location is raising concern for the local community.

Protesters Appeal To City Commission Over Confederate Statue

Protesters seeking to remove the downtown statue of the Confederate soldier spoke to city officials for the first time since the campaign began in late June. This is the first of several efforts that will go on over the next two weeks among protesters who call for the County Commission to take down the statue.


Grace Marketplace Reflects On First Year

Grace Marketplace has served the local homeless community for one year. The community is part of a 10-year plan, conceived in 2005, to end homelessness.


John Denny, the head brewer and a co-owner of First Magnitude Brewing Co., poses with the growlers the brewery sells. Starting July 1, breweries can legally sell the 64-ounce size in Florida. Nicole Gomez / WUFT News

Gainesville Brewers Celebrate Legal 64-Ounce Growlers

As SB 186 goes into effect Wednesday, Gainesville brewers are preparing to celebrate. Breweries expect the 64-ounce growlers to attract people from outside the state that will come and patronize Florida’s growing craft beer industry.


The downtown clock has frozen in time. Currently the city is reviewing all avenues to resolve the problem but does not have a time table yet for the clock to start ticking again.

City Still Looking For Solution To Repair Historic Downtown Clock

The downtown Gainesville clock has stopped working. The city does not yet know the extent of the problem, but is looking into how long it will take to fix.


Thank you for your support

WUFT depends on the support of our community — people like you — to help us continue to provide quality programming to North Central Florida.
Become a Sustainer
I want to support FM 89.1/NPR
I want to support Florida's 5/PBS
Donate a Vehicle
Underwriting Payments