Alachua County Sheriff Sadie Darnell, left, and Chief Deputy David Huckstep present their 2018-19 budget request to county commissioners in May 2018. (Courtesy of Alachua County)

Judge Rules In Favor of Alachua County Sheriff In Budget Dispute With County Commissioners


A circuit court judge ruled Friday in favor of the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office on its ability to retain more control over its budget rather than relinquishing some decisions to the Board of County Commissioners.

Judge Monica Brasington of the 8th Judicial Circuit denied county commissioners their request to gain oversight of changes to the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office budget, giving Sheriff Sadie Darnell the freedom to allocate money how she sees fit after each fiscal year begins.

Sheriff Sadie Darnell said she was pleased with the ruling from Friday and hopes that the relationship between the Sheriff’s Office and the County Commission will move forward smoothly.

“I’m hoping with the circuit court case determination that it will clear the air and answer any doubts they may have had with the operation of the budget,” she said.

Commission chairman Lee Pinkoson said, for him, the objective of the case was clear.

“Our people thought one way, the sheriff’s people thought another way. I thought, ‘Let’s go ahead and send it to the courts and get an answer,'” Pinkoson said.

Although pleased with the final result, Darnell said she was disappointed with the distraction the case brought to her operation since the lawsuit’s filing in early 2017.

“But it’s also it’s hindered the operation of my sheriff’s office, as well as the county staff,” she said. “They’ve been unnecessarily put to the task of researching the law and presenting this case in circuit court. It’s completely unnecessary.”

*This story has been updated to correctly attribute the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office. A previous version incorrectly attributed the “Alachua County Sheriff’s Department.” 

About Evan Denninghoff

Evan is a reporter for WUFT News who can be reached by calling 352-392-6397 or emailing

Check Also

Why There’s Little Sunshine On Many Economic Development Deals In Florida — And Beyond

State laws, including in Florida and neighboring states, are a patchwork of regulations that tend to land on the side of corporate secrecy, more often than not.


  1. It’s a SHERIFFS OFFICE Not a Department! The Florida Sheriffs do NOT work for the County Commission The Sheriff is a Constitutional Office!

    Chapter 30 is quite clear and older than most Statutes in Florida

    Quit bringing your northern Sheriff Dept philosophy to Southern Sheriffs. Not even close

  2. They do try these politicians to strong arm the sheriff department and make puppets out of them. In their positions they do not know what that department needs, and making them at every turn to go before the commissioners for money is as stupid as they are? A black eye for those that wanted the control of funds.Thank You

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *