What the U.S. Government Can and Can’t Legally Do Through NSA Snooping

By on June 14th, 2013
University of Florida professors Jon Mills and Clay Calvert, left to right, have this to say about NSA spying...

University of Florida

University of Florida professors Jon Mills and Clay Calvert, left to right, explain what the National Security Agency can and cannot do in collecting information while attempting to thwart terror attacks. Calvert also discussed the media's role during the past week of NSA leaks.

National Security Agency officials have come under fire in recent days for the news leak about its surveillance program, in which millions of Americans’ phone records and Internet activity are collected.

NSA Director General Keith Alexander told senators this week the program was necessary to protect the American people and has helped thwart dozens of possible terrorist threats.

Though media critics and legal experts say this may be true, there is concern that privacy rights are being violated.

Jon Mills, University of Florida Law professor and dean emeritus,  said while controversial, the program may have operated within constitutional limits.

“To view phone records, that is, just the phone number and the destination, it’s the same as email,” he said. “That type of surveillance is authorized. What isn’t authorized is looking at content.”

Clay Calvert, professor and director of the Marion B. Brechner First Amendment Project at the University of Florida, said there are personal ramifications from the NSA’s data mining.

“The idea is that by tracking phone numbers of who you’ve  called,” Calvert said, “they can back trace it to the people that you’re in contact with, how frequently you’re in contact with (them), and if those individuals in question have some compromising ties of their own.”

“Essentially, it could roll down on you,” he said.

While the NSA’s director divulged some information on Wednesday, even more important details likely were discussed in a classified briefing with the Senate Intelligence Committee on Thursday.

Because the public does not have direct access to the information, Calvert said people have to trust their representatives to look out for their best interests.

“The members of Congress who do hear that info, we have to trust them to serve as a check in some way on the NSA… If some members of Congress don’t like what they hear, you can bet they’ll hold a press conference about it.”

If the government went too far in its surveillance program, Mills said, people should be able to take that issue to court.

The problem arises in actually being aware of that overreach.

“If there are actually violations, litigation is the right thing to do,” he said. “If somebody’s personal privacy has been invaded and they know about it, they need to stand up for those rights.”

And as the discussion rages on stateside, the person responsible for leaking the classified information, Edward Snowden, is still in Hong Kong.

This entry was posted in National and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

More Stories in National

Steven Sotloff’s Parents Open Up As 1-Year Anniversary Nears

One year has passed since journalist Steven Sotloff’s beheading. Sotloff’s parents have a memorial foundation, which will give journalism students scholarships.

Boy Scout Flag Saluteat Gerald R. Ford MuseumBoy Scout Flag Salute at Gerald R. Ford Museum.

Boy Scouts Open Doors For Gay Leadership

Boy Scouts of America have lifted the ban on gay leadership, creating opportunities for increased membership and unit formation.

Crowd reactions - In a landmark opinion, the Supreme Court ruled Friday that states cannot ban same-sex marriage, establishing a new civil right and handing gay rights advocates a victory that until very recently would have seemed unthinkable.

Here’s What Local Folks Are Saying About Today’s Supreme Court Decision

The U.S. Supreme Court handed down a 5-4 decision today that states must recognize same-sex unions citing 14th Amendment protections. Here are some reactions from Florida:

12 Missing After Flooding In Texas Sweeps Away Vacation Home

Severe weather continued to impact towns in Oklahoma and Texas over the holiday weekend. The tornadoes and floods have taken a toll on the surrounding communities, leaving residents to salvage their belongings left in the aftermath. The recent flood in Central Texas has left 12 missing along the Blanco River.

Death Toll From Defective GM Ignition Switches Rises To 104

Faulty ignition switches in small GM cars has caused at least 104 deaths. Kenneth Feinberg, GM’s attorney, is offering victims’ families compensation for their loses.

Thank you for your support

WUFT depends on the support of our community — people like you — to help us continue to provide quality programming to North Central Florida.
Become a Sustainer
I want to support FM 89.1/NPR
I want to support Florida's 5/PBS
Donate a Vehicle
Underwriting Payments