Home / Environment / Why Wishful Thinking Leads To ‘Wishful Recycling’ Problems In Alachua County

Why Wishful Thinking Leads To ‘Wishful Recycling’ Problems In Alachua County


Charles Hobson has 40 years in the recycling industry under his belt.

Hobson serves as the Material Recovery Manager for the Leveda Brown Environmental Park & Transfer Station.

He got his start as a machine operator and worked his way up to the manager position.

Now he’s working at an Alachua County center that deals with recycling and waste management, which means they deal with what’s known as “wishful recycling.”

Wishful recycling is when a consumer hopes that a good is recyclable and puts it in their collection bin, but in reality, that slows down the recycling operation.

The center processes around 18,000 tons of recyclable material a year.

“It can be really confusing because there are a lot of recycling errors, catching errors on containers and things,” Hobson said. “If you’re not in the industry, you don’t understand.”

Alachua County relies on a dual-stream system, meaning one bin for paper and another for plastic.

“A lot of it is recycling — we just need to get it to the right place,” Hobson said.

Under the current system, five percent of the collected material is contaminated with wishful recycling.

Back in the 1980s, the county used a single stream recycling collection. That caused 30 to 40 percent of the material processed to be unusable.

Patrick Irby, the Waste Alternatives Manager at Alachua County, said the main consequence is the multiple processing fees.

“When recycling gets delivered to the materials recovery facility there is an expense to drop it. So they pay a fee for however many tons they’re bringing in, dump it off and go on their way,” Irby said.

Irby explains that there is an added cost being absorbed, including sorting fees and garbage processing.

Hobson deals with that impact directly.

“We all pay our price. We get charged to dump it at the transfer station, then the transfer station has to turn around and haul it to the landfill,” Hobson said.

At each drop-off station there is a processing fee, which causes the extra cost to start adding up in a big way.

“We want to recycle everything that we can, but unfortunately when there’s a lot of wishful recycling going on, it just increased the cost of that to go to the landfill,” Hobson said.

People who recycle play the biggest role: By sorting recyclables correctly, more materials can ultimately be reused.

The county participates in community outreach, specifically through local schools. Irby explains that kids will go home and tell their parents what they learned, passing on the message.

“When it comes to recycling, there’s energy savings, there’s resource savings, there’s saving landfill space, and you don’t have to make a new landfill. There’s all kinds of benefits,”  Irby said. “It’s a great opportunity for us to do a little part at every house.”

Every county has different guidelines for what’s recyclable.

In Alachua County, the center will recycle containers that have a pourable spout or neck up to 2 gallons in size, as well as yogurt cups and margarine tubs.

They ask for residents to rinse these plastics, removing all caps and lids.

More information for any specific questions can be found on this county website link.

About Daphna Krause

Daphna is a reporter at WUFT News who can be reached by calling 352-392-6397 or emailing news@wuft.org.

Check Also

Community Members Work To Decrease Local Plastic Waste

The Alachua County Library Headquarters Branch hosted an event to educate on local sustainability to reduce plastic waste after the repeal of the plastic bag ban.


  1. I wish a list would have been included here of what can be recycled qnd what ccmmon mistakes are being made.

    • Here is the list —

      I agree common mistakes would have also been a great addition.

    • Natalie Christine

      Seriously! Why isn’t there a list of what we can/can’t recycle! Such a missed opportunity!

    • It’s a list, but it’s not a very inclusive one. I’ve spoken to ACR about it and they don’t see a problem with what they’re doing, but i pointed out that they’re saying “recycle, but don’t make any mistakes” while simultaneously not explaining what is and is not a mistake. It’s disheartening for a recycler and environmentally conscious person such as myself. If they only recycle three types of plastic and two of them are “margarine tubs and yogurt cups”, that’s pretty pathetic. I suspect they can (and do) recycle more but they won’t tell us! Are we helping by including more plastic of the same types or are we breaking the system?

  2. What seems to be missing in this discussion is what is recycling. What happens in our area is collection of materials to be recycled. The actual recycling occurs somewhere else. It would be nice if we were told where the materials are actually recycled and what they are turned into. What percentage of the materials that are shipped from Alachua County are recycled into a new product? How much energy is used to get the collected materials to the location where they are recycled? Reducing and reusing provide much greater environmental benefits than recycling.

  3. I read this article thinking it would enlighten me on what possible mistakes I’ve been making and how I could improve my recycling efforts. But the writer missed the crucial take away by not addressing that.

    • Ditto. The author could have taken the opportunity to educate the readers who, because they are reading the article, are probably enthusiastic recyclers.

  4. I read that China has changed the contamination level they are willing to accept from us dropping 15% to 5% or less. Contamination refers to paper packaging contaminated by pizza grease, bottles that are not adequately rinsed and the like. I have read that shipping containers bound for China’s recycling have been rejected and are staking up here in the U.S. The infrastructural upgrading required here at home will take a decade to cope. I am under the impression it is purely a cheap labor/ profit issue. Also, periodically I hear that fluctuations of energy prices have an effect on the recycle industry. I am still confused about types of plastic suitable for recycling as well as types of paper coated with modern surfaces and all kinds of container lids. Would you provide me with an appropriate up to date web address?

  5. Natalie Christine

    Why isn’t there a list of what we can/can’t recycle! Such a missed opportunity!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *