Home / Education / Concerns Raised About Corporal Punishment in North Central Florida Schools

Concerns Raised About Corporal Punishment in North Central Florida Schools


Student Discipline DataMore students get paddled in the Suwannee County School District than anywhere else in Florida.

That highest ranking comes even though Suwannee is one of the least populated counties in the state. Out of the 67 counties in Florida, only 28 reported using corporal punishment during the 2011-12 academic year.

According to Tiffany Cowie, spokeswoman for the Florida Department of Education, Suwannee reported 359 students received corporal punishment during the 2012-13 school year.

Corporal punishment is still a routine practice in public schools throughout the United States. There are 19 states that still engage in this form of penalty.

According to the Florida Department of Education Student Information Database, during the 2011-12 school year, 360 students received corporal punishment in the Suwannee County School District.

When asked about the county’s high number of corporal punishment incidents, Suwannee School District Superintendent Jerry Scarborough declined to comment.

“We have a serious problem here and it needs to be scrutinized,” said James McNulty, founder of Floridians Against Corporal Punishment in Public School.

As a civil rights and human rights activist, McNulty has recently made corporal punishment in Suwannee County the next mission of his campaign. He has already had success in Santa Rosa County. He said he is ready to focus on this county because of the alarming numbers of reported incidents.

McNulty’s passion for the movement is undeniable.

“It is in Florida’s public schools, of which I am a product of, that I first learned to hate, to fear, to hold contempt, to have feelings of rage and revenge,” he said. “Public school is where I also learned what violence was.”

The Suwannee County School District student code of conduct for the 2013-14 school year defines corporal punishment as “the moderate use of paddling in front of a certified adult witness by a principal/administrator may be necessary to maintain discipline or to enforce school rules.”

Although the code of conduct includes a permission form for parents to check yes or no to using the punishment on their children, there are many unanswered questions about the practices.

McNulty said the code of conduct does not specify the measurements of the instrument being used to hit the student, how many hits are being administered, what specific actions warrant corporal punishment, if there are gender restrictions (males hitting young females) and more.

“You will find that virtually anything goes,” McNulty said.

McNulty’s first pursuit was in Santa Rosa County, where months of opposition ended with a victory. According to the Northwest Florida Daily News, school officials will abolish corporal punishment, also known as “paddling”, in the student code of conduct for the 2014-15 school year.

He recalls the tedious process that went on for many months; endless public record requests, ignored emails and phone calls, and frenzied school board meetings. McNulty’s determination and perseverance marked a milestone in Santa Rosa County, but only a minor accomplishment in his civil rights campaign.

McNulty first became involved when he was at work and overheard two parents discussing school officials calling them for approval to paddle their teenage high school daughters.

Marie Caton, a parent of a Santa Rosa County student, initially said yes and gave permission to use corporal punishment on her 10-year-old son. It was after seeing “the deepest shade of black and purple” on her son’s body when the guilt ensued for giving permission, she said.

“These people are paid and hired by the state to protect our children, not physically hurt them,” Caton said. “As educated people you’d think they could come up with something better than punishment with a board.”

McNulty is currently awaiting requested public records of the recent school year for Suwannee County.

However, eliminating the use of corporal punishment does not alleviate the problem of student misbehavior.

“The use of out of school suspension should not be increased due to a reduction in the use of corporal punishment,” said Joseph Gagnon, association professor in special education at the University of Florida. “To do so, would be to replace one ineffective method of intervention with another ineffective method.”

Last year, Gagnon was approached by the Southern Poverty Law Center and teamed up with Professor Brianna Kennedy-Lewis to conduct the study “Disciplinary Practices in Florida Schools.”

According to the study, corporal punishment models and teaches that violence is an effective approach to solving problems. It also said paddling only punishes misbehavior and doesn’t teach positive social behavior.

After surveying Title I school principals, Gagnon noted these schools haven’t implemented policies that “prevent problem behavior and promote appropriate behavior.”

The intensive study offers recommendations concerning the use of corporal punishment starting with the immediate abolition of corporal punishment in Florida schools.

According to the study, individualized intervention and positive behavior intervention and support are shown to promote social and emotional learning for students.

He recommends “ongoing professional development to help educators, school staff and administrators implement evidence-based alternatives to corporal punishment and other ineffectual punishments.”

“We think we’re so advanced in the United States, but South Africa outlawed corporal punishment 20 years ago,” Gagnon said. “We’re not always ahead of the curve.”

About Perri Konecky

Perri is a reporter for WUFT News who may be contacted by calling 352-392-6397 or emailing news @wuft.org

Check Also

UF Stadium, The Swamp

Students To See Financial Aid Expansion

As Florida students return to universities and state colleges this month for a new academic year, many will benefit from a major expansion of need-based financial aid.

  • nblock

    Suwannee children received over three hundred swats with a paddle? Are the children there worse than other children in FL? Are their teachers poorer? No, as long is corporal punishment is permitted, it will be used and as long is corporal punishment is permitted, children will be injured because it is easy to step over the line and hit too hard. Congratulations to Florida child advocates who are trying to end this barbaric practice as over l00 countries have done and 31 states have done in the US. See http://www.stophitting.org for laws, alternatives, and research and read Breaking the Paddle: Ending School Corporal Punishment to find out how parents can protect their children from paddling and end this practice for all children.

  • When you have this much violence going on in a supposedly “safe place” of learning–something is very wrong. How is it that educators in most of our nation are able to educate every single day without striking a human being? How are these deans, teachers, and school administrators qualified in hitting people? What college curriculum or courses did they ever complete that approved of this treatment of school students? None! They have been taught that this is wrong–but they never learned it. When an educator (and I use the term loosely, as criminal may be more appropriate) has to use his/her wooden weapon of violence in order to teach, they have ceased to be able to educate, and have failed. Many third world countries have forbid what is being carried out here. Stop the violence in our public schools in the United States of America!

  • KidsRpeople2

    Please sign and share Petition to Congress to enact Congresswoman Carolyn McCarthy D NY federal bill “The Ending Corporal Punishment in Schools Act” to withhold federal funding from educational institutions that allow corporal punishment of students, includes 30 minute Documentary Movie “The Board of Education” Exposing the brutally violent Truth about U.S. Public School Corporal Punishment of Children k-12 http://chn.ge/QaERCo

  • Megan Reeves

    Such a great story! Very impressed.

  • Jinji

    I know our education system is failing young people in many ways but I thought corporal punishment was a thing of the past. Violence is a learned behavior, so in using violence to punish a child, not only is psychological trauma inflicted, http://www.apa.org/monitor/2012/04/spanking.aspx the ultimate lesson learned from the exchange is that violence is an acceptable form of self expression. The “do as a say not as I do” parenting philosophy is a failed and inherently hypocritical approach to raising children. Children keenly understand unfairness and will do as you do until they learn a better way is possible.This viscous cycle has to end.