Home / Environment / What’s Wrong With Otter Creek’s Water?

What’s Wrong With Otter Creek’s Water?


In Otter Creek right now, a glass of water looks like green tea.

Freshly laundered whites look gray.

And access to the nearest drinkable tap water requires a 12-mile drive.

Thirty-five miles from Gainesville, in the town of Otter Creek, there is no drinking water. Routine screenings by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection have found levels of contaminants above the agency’s drinking water standards, which could increase the drinker’s risk of getting cancer.

Otter Creek’s 134 residents are going to nearby cities like Chiefland to buy bottled water or fill their jugs with clean tap water. Since August 2011, the Otter Creek Water Treatment Plant has been operating under Consent Order with the FDEP after routine tests showed contaminants in the water.

Otter Creek Mayor Cleah Martin said not even pets are drinking.

“They don’t drink that stuff,” Martin said. “Even the chickens drink bottled water.”

All drinking water systems are required to add a disinfectant, typically chlorine, to make water potable. According to the FDEP, when the chlorine comes into contact with organic material in the ground water, disinfection byproducts form.

This is the problem with Otter Creek’s water, which contains high levels of trihalomethanes and haloacetic acids.

Though there is no immediate risk to their health, customers of Otter Creek’s Water Treatment Plant receive quarterly public notices that some people who drink the contaminated water in excess over many years may experience healths problems such as a increased risk of getting cancer, and problems with liver, kidneys or central nervous system

Right now, Otter Creek is negotiating with the City of Chiefland to build a 12-mile pipeline from the southernmost point of water service in Chiefland to a bulk storage tank in Otter Creek.

Jacksonville engineer Joseph Mittauer is working with the town to design the pipeline. He said finding an affordable solution to the water problem has been difficult.

“If you were GRU and you had a big community, the mayor could have had this problem solved a long time ago,” Mittauer said. “But she doesn’t have the multi-million dollar pool of money to dip into and then be able to spread that bill among a bunch of rate payers. That’s the challenge in a small community. It’s not only getting the money initially but also making something that’s affordable or tries to be affordable.”

Mayor Martin says most Otter Creek residents are elderly and retired, and job opportunities are scarce.

The pipeline project will cost approximately $3 million though Mittauer said most, if not all, of the cost will be covered by state and federal grants. He said he expects the grants to come in by late summer or fall of next year, and hopes to see the pipeline completed in 2015.

Even with state and federal funding, Otter Creek residents can expect their monthly water bills to double or even triple in order to cover remaining project costs and purchase the water from Chiefland .

Chiefland City Manager Kevin Gay said his biggest concern with the project is that Otter Creek may not be able to afford the pipeline in the long run. He said the town’s population is declining, and may end up having trouble paying Chiefland for the water they use.

To move forward with plans for the pipeline, the Chiefland City Commission needs to give the project a final approval.

In the meantime, Mayor Martin and other Otter Creek residents are drinking water they’ve bought or poured in Chiefland and washing their clothes with murky water.

Check Also

Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Biologist Wade Brenner (left) and a volunteer unload a Florida black bear ready to be weighed at the check station located off of Forest Road 11 and CR 316 at the Ocala National Forest on Oct. 24. Although the hunt ended the next day after 295 bears were killed, speculation abounds as to whether baiting was behind that high number.  Andrea Cornejo/ WUFT News

Early End to Bear Hunt Raises Concerns Over Baiting

Claims of illegal baiting during Florida's 2015 Black Bear hunting season stir controversy. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission plans to issue an in-depth analysis of the hunt in a few weeks.