WUFT News

UF Law symposium discusses Stolen Valor Act

By on March 14th, 2013

The Stolen Valor Act was the focus on this year’s Media Law Symposium hosted by the University of Florida Levin College of Law.

The symposium, held Thursday in the Martin H. Levin Advocacy Center at the law school, featured a reception at 11:30 a.m., a panel at noon and a Q-and-A session afterward. It was organized by UF’s Journal of Law and Public Policy, who chose the topic of discussion.

Kara Carnley, editor-in-chief of the journal, said the topic was chosen because it has become such a focus of the Supreme Court.

The Stolen Valor Act makes it illegal to knowingly benefit from lying about receiving awards for military service. An updated version was recently introduced to the House of Representatives.

Col. Michael Smidt, staff judge advocate with U.S. Special Operations Command, said there is a clear difference in this update.

“The versions that I’ve seen have some requirements that the person knowingly tells a falsehood, and then they attempt to obtain some benefit as a result of that falsehood,” he said. “The original was if you claimed that you had an award that you didn’t have, that was enough to be criminally prosecuted.”

Smidt was one of four panelists. He said he understands why the Stolen Valor Act has become such a focus for members of the military.

“I’m sworn to uphold the Constitution,” he said, “so whatever our civilian leadership decides that means — the judiciary and political branch — that’s what we’re going to adhere to, that’s what we do as soldiers. We adhere to the decisions made by others. But that doesn’t mean we can’t have personal feelings.”

The other panelists were Lyrissa Lidsky, a media law professor at UF; Craig D. Feiser, a First Amendment and media law attorney; and Kristen Rasmussen, an attorney who wrote the amicus brief presented to the Supreme Court for the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.

Carnley said the members of the panel were chosen because they are a well-rounded group of experts who will be able to address all of the different topics regarding the Stolen Valor Act and the Alvarez case, which was the first court case related to lying about receiving a medal of honor.

Students were given the opportunity to interact with professionals in the field who might be practicing in an area of interest to them.

Smidt hoped this symposium would help him to learn more from his fellow panelists and students in the audience, who would also hopefully benefit from the discussion.

“I think what will happen is, between the members of the panel, maybe the students will be exposed to ideas that aren’t necessarily captured in the opinions of the court, because, you know, they only have so much time and so much expertise,” he said. “And I think by bringing in people from a wide spectrum of the marketplace of ideas, they’ll be exposed to a lot of different thoughts and perspectives.”


This entry was posted in University of Florida and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
 

More Stories in University of Florida

Robert Alan Black, Ph.D., spoke with WUFT News on Wednesday about his experience in the United Arab Emirates after he was arrested. Like University of Professor John Schueller, Ph.D., Black was arrested for taking photographs in a restricted area.

Georgia Man Previously Arrested In UAE Sheds Light On UF Professor’s Situation

University of Florida professor John Schueller, Ph.D., is still detained after being arrested in Abu Dhabi on March 9. The circumstances of his arrest, though, are not uncommon.


schueller

UF Engineering Professor Detained In United Arab Emirates

University of Florida professor John Schueller, Ph.D., was in Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates for a conference. The U.S. State Department confirmed his situation.


Painting major, Rachel Lewis adds finishing touches to her sculpture.

UF Creativity Event Invites Collaboration Between Art and Science Majors

An event Jan. 31 allowed students to work together on art and science projects. The UF College of the Arts and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute Science for Life Program aimed to bring together art and science majors.


Sgt. Eddie King of the University of Florida Police Department stands in front of lockers that hold weapons currently not allowed on campus. Students who wish to bring their guns with them can store them at UPD and check them out at any time.

Concealed Carry Bill Raises Concerns About Campus Safety

A bill making its way through the Florida Legislature would allow anyone with a concealed weapon license can carry his or her weapon legally on a public university campus.


This artist's rendering shows the interior of the University of Florida's planned indoor football practice facility.

UAA Announces Plans For Indoor Football Practice Facility

The UAA announced plans on Wednesday for the construction of an indoor football practice facility expected to be completed September 2015. The project is estimated at $15 million and will be located at the site of the Sanders Football Practice Fields.


Thank you for your support

WUFT depends on the support of our community — people like you — to help us continue to provide quality programming to North Central Florida.
Become a Sustainer
I want to support FM 89.1/NPR
I want to support Florida's 5/PBS
Donate a Vehicle
Underwriting Payments