WUFT News

State Supreme Court hears oral arguments in pension case

By on September 10th, 2012

The Florida Supreme Court heard oral arguments Friday regarding a lawsuit filed by  government workers challenging a 2011 law that requires public employees to contribute to their retirement plans.

“It is a common sense public pension reform,” said Lane Wright, press secretary for Florida Gov. Rick Scott. “Prior to this reform, Florida was one of only three states in the whole country that did not require public employees to contribute to their pensions.”

Alachua County Education Association President Karen McCann said the law violates Florida’s constitution.

“They changed the conditions of employement,” she said. “We had a contract. The Florida constitution says in Article I, Section 10 that you cannot pass a law that breaks an existing contract, and that’s what the lawsuit is really about.”

McCann said prior to the 2011 law it was a condition of employment that state employees, such as teachers and firefighters, receive a pension paid for by the employer. She said the law violates the rights of anyone who was employed by the state prior to 2011 and had a pension with the Florida Retirement System.

The state “made up the budget shortfall on the backs of a lot of middle class workers by breaking a promise that the state had to them,” she said.

Wright said the state expects to win the case based on a precedent set by the state Supreme Court more than three decades ago.

“The truth is more than 30 years ago there was a decision made by the Florida Supreme Court that said the legislature is allowed to make changes to the Florida Retirement System on a going-forward-basis,” he said. “And when the legislature crafted this law they were careful to make sure they followed that precedent that was set more than 30 years ago. ”

It is unknown when the state Supreme Court will release its decision.

Emily Miller edited this story for online.

 


This entry was posted in Florida and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
 

More Stories in Florida

First Magnitude Brewing Company in Gainesville fills growlers in the 32-ounce size (left) and the gallon size (right). A longstanding ban on the popular 64-ounce growler prevents Florida craft breweries from filling or selling containers of that size.

Lawmakers Pass Bill To Aid Craft Brewers, End Growler War

Senate Bill 186 could end a long war between craft brewers and big beverage distributors over regulation of beer sales. The bill lifts the problematic requirement that craft breweries operate as tourist attractions and allows the breweries to sell beer in the popular 64-ounce, refillable “growler.”


The FSU Veterans Center is pushing for a bill to allow student veterans to pay in-state tuition. The attention their cause has received nationwide has given them hope they may succeed this year.

Bill Passed To Let Child Rape Victims Record Attackers

The Florida Legislature is sending Gov. Rick Scott a bill that would let children who are victims or potential victims of rape and other violent acts secretly record their attackers. The bill applies to victims who are under the age of 18.


bell7

Abortion Waiting Period Bill Goes To Florida Governor

A bill to require a 24-hour waiting period for abortions is headed to Republican Gov. Rick Scott’s desk. The Senate voted 26-13 for the measure Friday after about an hour of debate.


The Alachua County Clerk of Court, located at 201 East University Ave., remained closed Saturday, April 18 during Operation Green Light. Assistant Clerk of Court Edward Stiles said that it would be too expensive to remain open for the promotion.

Waived Fees Help Drivers Save Money On Traffic Citations

As an effort to help traffic violators pay off citations, Clerks in the state of Florida initiated the money saving opportunity Operation Green Light. On Saturday, Alachua County hosted the promotion to waive fees to help residents cut the cost on paying off their citations.


Screen Shot

UF Students Welcome Bill Proposing Tax-Free Textbooks

A new law in Florida could help students save money on expensive textbooks. The bill looks to eliminate the sales tax from textbooks to give students a break on the hundreds they already spend on required texts.


Thank you for your support

WUFT depends on the support of our community — people like you — to help us continue to provide quality programming to North Central Florida.
Become a Sustainer
I want to support FM 89.1/NPR
I want to support Florida's 5/PBS
Donate a Vehicle
Underwriting Payments